Buy-to-let affordability is a key factor when securing finance for investment properties. Whether you’re a seasoned landlord or purchasing your first rental, understanding how lenders assess buy-to-let (BTL) affordability can make or break your mortgage application. Lenders don’t just look at your income; they assess whether the expected rental income can comfortably cover the mortgage, even under stress-test conditions.
With 2022 seeing tighter lending criteria, tax implications, and AI-driven affordability models, having a clear strategy to meet affordability requirements is more important than ever for successful property investment.
What Is Buy to Let Affordability?
Buy-to-let affordability is how lenders determine whether your expected rental income will cover mortgage repayments, typically using an Income Coverage Ratio (ICR). Most lenders require that rental income meets 125% to 145% of the monthly mortgage payments, based on a stress-tested interest rate (commonly 5.5%+).
The calculation depends on:
-
Rental income forecast
-
Stress rate used for testing affordability
-
Tax status (basic vs higher rate taxpayer)
-
Property type (HMO, single let, multi-unit, etc.)
-
Loan type (interest-only or repayment)
Challenges faced by mortgage advisers
Mortgage advisers specialising in Buy-to-Let affordability have had to confront several hurdles during this period of market flux. The unpredictability of rate adjustments has necessitated rapid application submissions, often with less preparation time than desired. This heightened pace can increase the likelihood of application errors, and some lenders have shown limited flexibility in addressing these mistakes. Consequently, advisers have sometimes had to resubmit applications, leading to the loss of favourable rates.
Tips for Mortgage Advisers
If you’re a broker advising on BTL affordability, ensure your network offers access to a wide lender panel and provides tools like real-time affordability calculators. Our mortgage networks for advisers offer compliance support and access to specialist BTL lenders.
Mortgage Market Settles, But Affordability Pressures Remain
The mortgage market has shown signs of stabilisation; however, buy-to-let affordability challenges continue to weigh on investors. Since the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) introduced stricter affordability criteria in 2016, 5-year fixed-rate mortgages have become a staple. These rules require affordability assessments based on a hypothetical 5.5% rate. Yet with many current 5-year fixes exceeding this threshold due to ongoing interest rate increases, affordability pressures are intensifying.
Discount Rates Complicate Buy-to-Let Calculations
Although discount rates have supported affordability in the residential space, they’ve created new complexities in the buy-to-let sector. Many lenders now use notional stress rates significantly above 5.5%, with some climbing as high as 8.5%. This inflated stress testing reduces loan-to-value (LTV) ratios for new landlords. Investors who’ve recently used bridging finance to acquire properties may struggle to raise the capital needed for refinance or repayment.
The Growing Risk of Mortgage Prisoners
Landlords who previously secured 5-year fixed deals below 4% are approaching their remortgage dates. Given today’s higher rates and tighter affordability stress tests, many could be unable to refinance under similar terms. This raises concerns over a rising number of buy-to-let mortgage prisoners, landlords effectively stuck due to restrictive affordability recalculations.
Retention Rates Offer Breathing Space
To help landlords navigate rate pressures, some lenders, particularly specialists, have introduced retention rate options. These allow borrowers to stay on more favourable terms without meeting stricter new affordability checks. Seasoned investors are also using rate review windows to release equity for property upgrades or new acquisitions. This could become increasingly common if regulatory upgrades (such as EPC improvements) are mandated.
Advisers Become Key to Investor Success
In this evolving landscape, the value of experienced buy-to-let mortgage advisers has never been higher. Advisers who understand the full range of lender criteria and emerging product solutions can offer vital guidance. This includes spotting opportunities across specialist lending, rate strategies, and portfolio structuring to maximise affordability.
Explore how advisers benefit from access to a wider lender panel in our Mortgage Networks for Advisers guide.
Unlocking PRA’s Like-for-Like Remortgage Rules
If a borrower’s current lender doesn’t offer suitable retention terms, advisers can turn to the PRA’s like-for-like remortgage provisions. These rules allow lenders to use their own discretion when choosing the rate applied to affordability assessments, offering flexibility in borderline cases.
Understanding Margin Variations
Lenders apply varying margin thresholds, often between 125% and 145% especially for higher-rate taxpayers purchasing in personal names. While the PRA sets minimum requirements, individual lender interpretations create room for advisers to optimise affordability by tailoring margin selection to the client’s financial profile.
Top-Slicing: A Valuable Affordability Tool
Top-slicing, in which surplus income or rental income is factored into affordability calculations, is increasingly embraced by lenders. Some providers accept margin thresholds as low as 110% using this method, making it a practical option for landlords facing affordability shortfalls.
Alternative Property Strategies
When conventional affordability assessments become a hurdle, alternative property types can offer a solution. High-yielding investments such as holiday lets or HMOs (houses in multiple occupation) often deliver higher rental returns, helping meet stricter affordability requirements.
Lenders like HTB and Fleet Mortgages offer tailored underwriting for these properties, allowing more flexibility in assessment. Learn more in our specialist mortgage network for advisers guide.
Looking Ahead: Innovation Amid Affordability Pressure
Despite the affordability squeeze, lender appetite remains strong. New solutions and innovative mortgage products are expected to emerge throughout 2025, helping investors stay active in the market.
With a solid grasp of lending trends, top-slicing tools, and access to specialist networks, buy-to-let advisers are well positioned to guide clients through this complex environment, helping them achieve long-term property goals with confidence.
We have reached the end of our publication on “Buy to Let Affordability | Connect Talks Challenges and Opportunities.” Stay “Connect” until next time!